I didn’t set out to become an integrative psychiatrist.
Like most doctors out there, I went through medical school and residency learning a “disease-based” approach of how the human body works. First, we learned what “normal” was. Then, we learned all the ways normal could go wrong. Our goal was to recognize, diagnose, and treat symptoms and diseases.
Even at the time, though, I couldn’t help but wonder – What about the person with the symptoms or disease? Who is she? What’s her story? What went wrong with her body, heart or mind that brought her to my office?
Questions like these drew me to psychiatry, which is a field where doctors actually have a decent amount of time to talk to patients and hear their stories. But even in psychiatry we have a diagnostic manual that focuses on all the things that can go wrong with the mind, instead of learning from and being inspired by people who live particularly happy, balanced and fulfilling lives.
So over time my focus on this blog shifted from talking about psychiatry and psychology in general to talking about a positive view of psychiatry.
When I first made this shift, I got a lot of comments from people ready to cheer me on for eschewing traditional psychiatric treatments like medications. These people were pretty disappointed to learn that I am definitely not anti-medication, or anti-psychiatry for that matter.
Sorry, but I didn’t go to school studying medicine and biology for my entire adult life only to throw out a vast body of scientific literature and personal experience indicating that traditional treatments can be very helpful.
Instead, I strive to take a wise and balanced approach. I think that anyone who is too far on one side of the fence (either wanting to throw a pill at any negative emotion, or wanting to blame medications for for all of society’s ills) is probably missing the point.
So what does integrative psychiatry mean, anyway?
1. Optimal mental wellness is the goal, not just the absence of disease. It’s not enough to be “not depressed” or “not anxious.” Why do we think this is a good enough place to stop? Happiness, fulfillment and joy in everyday life should be the bar we set.
2. Relationships have a healing power. I mean both an individual’s personal relationships and social support networks, which have been demonstrated in too many studies to cite to be crucial in overall health and well-being, as well as that individual’s relationship with her psychiatrist.
I have therapy patients who seem to benefit from our relationship more than any other intervention I do. Being heard and cared for is important. Really important.
3. The body, mind and environment operate as a whole. You can not treat symptoms without understanding the context in which those symptoms arose. Why are you feeling anxious? What is happening in your life, your work, your relationships, your body? All of these factors must be understood and addressed.
4. The money is in prevention. It’s not about waiting for a disease to happen and then putting a bandaid over it. It’s about promoting a healthy mindset (whether through diet, exercise, meditation, spirituality, cultivating relationships, etc…) that makes problems less likely to arise, and gives you more capacity to deal with them when they do.
5. We all have an innate healing power. Our natural state of being is healthy, not sick. This is good news! It means that if you feel unhappy, or stuck, or restless, you need only to identify the obstacles that are keeping you from healing and then remove them.
6. Treatment modalities should be integrated. Hence “integrative” psychiatry. The best of conventional medical and psychiatric diagnostic techniques and treatments can be combined with alternative strategies such as mindfulness, herbal supplements, acupuncture, massage, and other complementary approaches.
7. We have personal responsibility for our health and happiness. You may not find this piece is the definition of integrative psychiatry elsewhere, but to me it’s essential. Joy, happiness and fulfillment are not things that some psychiatrist of therapist can give you. You must decide that these are goals worth striving for and be willing to let go of negative habits so you can get them.
8. Individuality should be honored. Not all bodies or minds work the same, and we all have different treatments and techniques that resonate with us. To the utmost degree possible, a person’s preferences should be a crucial factor in determining what strategies are used to help them.
9. The practitioner must teach by example. I’d be a pretty big hypocrite if I went around telling people to take my (metaphorical) medicine if I didn’t take it myself. I’m far from perfect and have a few bad habits I’m trying to let go of, but I try to live a healthy life and practice the principles I preach.
10. All life experiences are learning opportunities. Even, or maybe especially, the bad ones. I know that the the points in my life when I’ve failed the biggest or suffered the most have been when the most important realizations have come. These experiences should be honored instead of ignored or minimized.
As you can see, integrative psychiatry is not about prescribing St John’s Wort instead of Prozac, but is rather an entire approach for striving for mental health and wellness.
And yes, I prescribe Prozac, too.
Photo by Doug
Shavon Moore says
As a second year medical student pretty set on the path towards psychiatry its refreshing to read number one and see there will soon be practicing attending that will not settle for the absence of the disease but bringing overall health and happiness to a patient even when symptoms have become long gone. Best of luck to you and your future practice!
Lois Parkison says
So glad to have discovered you, Elana, in surfing the net to see what I could find on ‘integrative psychiatry’. I’ve been on my own journey of integrating preventative self-care (particularly mindfulness, nutrition, and exercise), psychoanalytically-oriented psychotherapy, and a Western medical psychiatric approach into my San Francisco-based private psychiatric practice– in an authentic, open way–which is what I see you doing here. Am looking forward to reading more of what you have to share.
Dr Vijay Girdhar says
Hello… good mmorning…this is Dr Vijay Girdhar…. Medical officer, in charge of psychiatry department, Government multi speciality hospital, Chandigarh India…. I came across your ideas while surfing the net for ‘integrative psychiatry ‘….& am really glad to know that your ideas exactly resonate with my ideas….. I have been utilising energy healing modalities, hypnotherapy& past life regression therapy with my clients and of course yoga and pranayam too….You seem to be doing a wonderful work….. great… keep it up….
Yay, my dream job is a thing!